The St. Paul Weekly Edit: All Hallow's Week

Blog

Metal eagle sculpture with outstretched wings perched on an ornate base.

The St. Paul Weekly Edit: What Happened This Week

Macalester-Groveland, Highland Park, Summit Hill, Summit University & Merriam Park | October 18 to 26, 2026

Busted. Unbothered. Still at it.

September caught the market in the act. Mortgage rates pushed past 7% for the first time since January 2025, and pending sales across Minnesota fell 11.5%, the steepest monthly drop of the year. In St. Paul, sales were down 9.2% from a year earlier. Those are real numbers, and they deserve a straight reading.

So the spotlight swung to central Saint Paul to see what it would do. It paused, looked the headlines in the eye, and went back to business. Eight homes closed across five of the city's most storied neighborhoods between October 18 and 26, and another 37 sit under contract. Buyers who are ready are still buying. They are simply negotiating with more confidence than they have in years, and this week shows where that confidence lands.

Macalester-Groveland

Macalester-Groveland recorded no new closings this week, so its sale figures carry forward from October 11 to 19: a median sale price of $410,000 and 98.8% of list price, based on three sales. Those three homes all closed at or under $500,000, which placed that median below where this neighborhood usually sits.

The current read is more telling. Median days on market stands at 24 days, drawn from this week's active and pending listings, and ten homes are under contract. A quiet closing week paired with a full pipeline is a matter of timing, not a slowdown. Those contracts will surface in the weeks ahead.

Highland Park

Highland Park carried the week. Six homes closed at a median sale price of $421,500, a median of 24 days on market, and 97.6% of list price. Five of the six sold under $600,000, which pulled the median well below last week's $730,000. That shift reflects which homes closed, not a change in what Highland Park homes are worth.

This is also where the negotiating story shows up most clearly. Five of the six closings landed below list price, and two included seller concessions. Even the week's top sale, a 1951 home on Lower Saint Dennis Road, closed at its full $1,250,000 list price in four days with a $35,000 concession attached. Buyers are paying the number when the home earns it, and asking for terms when they can.

Seventeen Highland Park homes are pending, the deepest contract count of the five neighborhoods for a second straight week.

Summit Hill

Summit Hill had no new closings this week. Its figures carry forward from last week: a $739,345 sale price at 96.6% of list, which was itself based on a single sale. Read it as a data point, not a trend.

Median days on market stands at 46 days, and only two homes are under contract against 21 active listings, much of that inventory priced well above $700,000. This is the tier where buyers take their time and negotiate with care. Notably, the September report found that pending sales over $1 million fell just 2.2% statewide, compared with a 12.8% drop for homes under $400,000. The upper end of the market is moving slowly, but it is holding.

Summit University

Summit University recorded a single closing, so this median rests on one sale. An 1888 home on Holly Avenue closed at $850,000, or 100.0% of its final list price, with a neighborhood median of 58 days on market.

The path matters here. That home originally listed at $875,000, so the final sale landed at 97.1% of the original ask after a price adjustment. It is a clean example of what the statewide report describes: the final number is increasingly found in the market rather than set before it.

Merriam Park

Merriam Park also recorded a single closing, so this figure is based on one sale. A 1915 home on Portland Avenue closed at $590,000, its full list price, in 15 days. The neighborhood's median days on market, drawn from all active, pending, and closed listings, stands at 30 days.

Seven Merriam Park homes are under contract, including a five-bedroom 1925 home on Summit Avenue listed at $1,495,000. The Portland Avenue sale is the week's clearest reminder that a home priced correctly from day one still sells quickly and without a discount, rates or no rates.

What September's Statewide Report Adds

The monthly view from Minnesota Realtors gives this week its context. Inventory across the Twin Cities metro climbed 11.2% to 12,411 homes, and months of supply rose from 2.9 to 3.2. That is still below the five to six months of a balanced market, but the direction is unmistakable. Metro homes took 48 cumulative days to reach an accepted offer, up from 44 a year ago, and sellers received 97.7% of their original list price, down from 98.4%.

Prices, meanwhile, held. The Twin Cities median sale price rose 1.3% to $395,000 even as sales slowed. The Federal Reserve raised its benchmark rate on September 16, and the 30-year fixed rate reached 7.4% on October 8, according to Freddie Mac. Because many September contracts were signed before rates peaked, the report expects closings to stay soft into the fall.

Early Signs of the Monthly Trend

Read side by side, the weekly and monthly data begin to rhyme. Highland Park's below-list closings and concessions, and the price adjustment behind the Summit University sale, show early signs of the statewide shift toward buyer leverage reaching specific streets. Early is the operative word. This was a mid-month window, when closings run light, and most of the month's sales land in its final days.

The counterpoint matters just as much. The Lower Saint Dennis and Portland Avenue homes both closed at full list price, one in four days and one in fifteen. Neither flinched. Underpricing does not create bidding wars, it simply leaves money behind. Accurate pricing from the first day is what protects a seller's number in a market like this one.

Why Days on Market Reads Higher Than Some Sales Suggest

Median days on market in The St. Paul Weekly Edit draws from every active, pending, and closed listing in each neighborhood during the reporting window, not from closings alone. That is why the Merriam Park home sold in 15 days while the neighborhood median reads 30. It also means a neighborhood with no closings still has a current days on market figure, which is why Macalester-Groveland and Summit Hill show this week's pace even as their sale figures carry forward.

The Micro View

Monthly reports, like the September update from Minnesota Realtors, show the broader trend: where rates are pushing, how inventory is building, which price bands are bending. That view is essential. The St. Paul Weekly Edit is the close-up, a neighborhood-by-neighborhood read that only comes from watching these five markets every single week.

A single high or low week is a moment, not a market. This week's carried figures and single-sale medians are a reminder of that. Next week's edit captures the month-end closings, the first fair test of whether central Saint Paul's composure holds. The truer read only reveals itself week to week, which is exactly why this edit returns every week.


Natasha Cejudo is a luxury real estate advisor with Lakes Sotheby's International Realty and a trusted local expert in Saint Paul real estate, specializing in Macalester-Groveland, Highland Park, Summit Hill, Summit University, and Merriam Park. In real estate since 2005 and a Macalester College alumna, Natasha publishes The St. Paul Weekly Edit to give buyers and sellers a granular, neighborhood-level read of the Saint Paul housing market, week by week.

Work With Natasha

Natasha prides herself on an honest, transparent, and comprehensive approach based on mutual understanding and clear communication. She is patient, insightful, attentive, and responsive; her professionalism, humor, and candid approach make her a joy to work with. If you are considering a move this year or next, she would welcome a conversation with you!